Best Waterproof Eye Pencil: Top Picks for 2024 You Can’t Miss!

Choosing the best waterproof eye pencil can be a game changer for those who desire long-lasting, smudge-proof makeup. In 2024, the demand for high-quality eye pencils that can withstand sweat, humidity, and even tears is at an all-time high. This article delves into the best waterproof eye pencils available on Amazon, providing detailed reviews of the top 10 products that stand out in the market for their performance and durability. Whether you’re looking for an eyeliner for everyday wear or a more dramatic look, our selection aims to help you find the best waterproof eye pencil to suit your needs.

1. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

The Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil is a cult favorite among makeup enthusiasts. Known for its creamy texture, this pencil glides on smoothly without pulling or tugging at the delicate skin around the eyes. Once applied, it dries quickly and remains budge-proof for up to 24 hours, making it one of the best waterproof eye pencils on the market.

Available in an array of vibrant colors, the Urban Decay pencil offers both bold and subtle shades. Its waterproof formula ensures that you can wear it all day long without fear of smudging or fading. A notable feature is its easy application, allowing for a precise line or a more blended effect depending on your desired look. Additionally, the pencil comes with a built-in sharpener, which is a practical benefit for on-the-go touch-ups.

In terms of customer reviews, this product consistently receives high praise for its longevity, pigmentation, and smooth application. Some users, however, note that it can be a bit difficult to remove at the end of the day, which speaks to its long-lasting performance.

This eye pencil is ideal for anyone seeking a reliable option for everyday use or special occasions, making it the best waterproof eye pencil for effective results.

2. Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

While more commonly known for liquid formulations, Stila has mastered the waterproof eye pencil category with its Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner. This pencil brings the precision of a liquid eyeliner in a convenience that comes in pencil form. Its fine tip allows for versatile application, from ultra-fine lines to dramatic wings.

The formula is water-resistant and offers impressive staying power, lasting throughout the day without smudging or fading. It dries quickly, which helps to maintain clean lines and vibrant color. Stila’s extensive color range ensures that there’s a perfect shade for everyone, catering to those looking for everything from classic black to unique hues.

Users rave about its longevity and easy-to-use design. Many highlight its opaque color payoff and minimal fading, making it an excellent choice for everyday wear and special occasions alike. A few reviewers mentioned that the pencil requires a bit of pressure during application for optimal results, but the payoff is worth it.

This is the best waterproof eye pencil for users who prioritize precision and versatility in their makeup routine.

3. NYX Professional Makeup Slide On Pencil

For those seeking an affordable yet highly effective waterproof eye pencil, the NYX Professional Makeup Slide On Pencil checks all the boxes. This eye pencil is designed to deliver intense color in one swipe, encompassing both affordability and performance.

The formula is creamy and glide-on, providing a smooth application without dragging the skin. It offers a nice range of shades, from classic black to vibrant colors. The waterproof quality ensures long-lasting wear, even in humid environments, making it a favorite among outdoor enthusiasts.

User feedback highlights the incredible color payoff and the fact that it stays put even on oily eyelids, a common concern for many. A minor drawback reported by some is that it can require reapplication throughout the day, especially for vibrant colors. However, for the price point and overall performance, many find this to be the best waterproof eye pencil for budget-conscious buyers.

4. Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio Sharpenable Gel Pencil

The Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio Sharpenable Gel Pencil is an excellent option that highlights affordability alongside high-quality performance. This gel-based pencil is smooth, easy to apply, and, most importantly, waterproof.

This eye pencil promises up to 36 hours of wear, making it perfect for those long days or nights out. The color intensity is impressive, ensuring that you achieve the desired look without needing multiple applications. Its gel formula allows for a softer finish compared to traditional pencils, which some users appreciate for a more natural look.

Customers have noted that the pencil is easy to sharpen and maintains its creamy consistency throughout its use. However, some have pointed out that the darker shades can occasionally fade after prolonged wear. Overall, it stands out as the best waterproof eye pencil in its price range.

No products found.

5. Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner

Smashbox’s Always On Gel Eyeliner is recognized for its high-performance formula that resists smudging while delivering a bold color payoff. The unique gel-like formula allows it to glide on smoothly, providing a soft finish while maintaining precision.

This eyeliner is waterproof and offers a long-lasting wear time that makes it suitable for all-day use without the need for touch-ups. The pencil is also retractable, eliminating the hassle of sharpening, and comes in a variety of shades to fit any style.

Users frequently note its blendability and versatility, allowing for both delicate lines and bolder styles. Its resistant nature to sweat and tears further solidifies its position as the best waterproof eye pencil for active individuals. Some users did mention a slight issue with crumbling, but those instances appear to be rare.

6. Clinique Quickliner for Eyes

Clinique’s Quickliner for Eyes is another fantastic option, offering a unique twist to the traditional pencil eyeliner. This automatic pencil features a thick, creamy formula that glides effortlessly onto the lash lines without pulling or irritation.

The waterproof aspect ensures a reliable performance, while the color options range from neutral to bold shades. An added perk is its dual-ended design which includes a blendable smudger on the other side, perfect for creating that smoky eye look.

Many users rave about its easy application and vibrant colors. It’s also praised for its long wear. However, a few noted that the formula could be prone to smudging throughout the day, especially in more humid climates. Despite this minor drawback, it remains a popular choice and can be considered one of the best waterproof eye pencils available.

7. Tarte Tartist™ Double Take Eyeliner

Tarte’s Tartist™ Double Take Eyeliner is a versatile product that combines both a gel pencil and a liquid liner in one. Providing options for various styles, this dual-ended pencil is perfect for those who enjoy a range of eyeliner looks.

This eye pencil features a waterproof formula that stays put for hours while delivering rich, deep colors. Users commend its easy glide-on application and the intense color payoff of the liquid liner side. Tarte prioritizes skin-friendly ingredients, making this liner suitable for sensitive skin types as well.

The only downside mentioned by users is that the gel side may run out faster than expected, but the overall effectiveness and dual utility earn it a top spot on this list of best waterproof eye pencils.

8. Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner

Revlon’s ColorStay Eyeliner is an iconic product that has stood the test of time. Its excellent waterproof formula ensures that you can trust it to stay in place throughout even the most demanding days.

The pencil design means it’s easy to apply and control, offering a classic way to achieve both bold and subtle lines. The ColorStay Eyeliner is known for its richly pigmented colors—ideal for making an impression without needing to layer multiple strokes.

User reviews frequently highlight its staying power and ease of application. Some, however, have reported that it can take extra effort to remove at the end of the day, which is a common trait of waterproof products. Overall, this is considered one of the best waterproof eye pencils for those who want an effective and reliable option.

9. Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Crayon

For those looking for a luxe option, the Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Crayon is a must-try. This gel formula feels luxurious and smooth upon application, providing a soft texture that’s easy to blend if desired.

This eye pencil is waterproof and delivers long-wearing results, making it suitable for various occasions. The immense color spectrum allows beauty enthusiasts to play up their eye makeup looks and create everything from classic lines to colorful accents.

Users rave about its creamy formulation and outstanding pigmentation. A few did note that it may be harder to control when not used with a primer, but these concerns are typically outweighed by its overall performance. This product truly embodies the essence of the best waterproof eye pencil in terms of quality and effectiveness.

10. L’Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner

Last but not least, the L’Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner offers incredible value at a drugstore price. This pencil is designed to last, with a formula that makes it resistant to smudging and fading.

With rich color payoff and effortless glide, it’s an effective choice for users of all skill levels. This eyeliner has become a favorite among those looking for a reliable daily-use product that can withstand the elements without breaking the bank.

Feedback praises its impressive staying power and ease of use but notes that the darker shades, while initially bold, can wear down towards the end of the day. Still, it remains one of the best waterproof eye pencils for anyone searching for quality on a budget.

No products found.

Buying Guide for the Best Waterproof Eye Pencil

When selecting the best waterproof eye pencil for your makeup kit, there are several factors to consider to ensure you find the right product for your needs. Here are some essential points to keep in mind:

1. Waterproof Formula

It might seem obvious, but ensure that the eye pencil specifically states that it is waterproof. Water-resistant products offer limited protection and may smudge in humid conditions. Waterproof formulations remain intact in sweat, tears, or rain, making them ideal for long days and nights.

2. Type and Texture

The texture of the eye pencil can significantly affect your makeup application. Gel-based pencils are typically creamier and smoother than traditional pencils, allowing for a more comfortable application. Consider whether you prefer a pencil that glides on easily or one that requires a bit of pressure for a bold line.

3. Color Range

A wide color range is essential to ensure that you can achieve the look you want. Whether you prefer classic black, rich brown, or vibrant colors, make sure the brand you choose offers options that suit your style.

4. Application and Removal

Some pencils are easier to apply than others. Opt for ones that allow for precision and smooth application. Additionally, consider how easy it is to remove the product at the end of the day. While waterproof formulas tend to resist fading, they can also be challenging to take off, requiring a good makeup remover.

5. Customer Reviews

Before making a purchase, it’s wise to look at customer feedback to gauge the product’s performance. Check for comments regarding longevity, color payoff, and application ease to ensure it aligns with what you’re looking for.

In conclusion, the market for waterproof eye pencils in 2024 is filled with fantastic options, making it easier than ever to choose products that can withstand daily wear and tear. From high-end brands to affordable options, every makeup lover can find the best waterproof eye pencil that meets their unique needs and preferences. With our list of the top 10 products and the buying guide provided, you can confidently embark on your search for the perfect eye pencil.

Last update on 2024-09-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API | votechriscarrillo.com is a participant in the Amazon Associate program and will earn from qualifying purchases.