Best Vintage Pencils: Top Picks for 2024 That Every Artist Needs

The world of stationery has always held a certain charm, particularly for those who appreciate the finesse of vintage writing instruments. In 2024, vintage pencils are not just tools for writing; they are collectible pieces of art that evoke nostalgia and elegance. We’ve searched through Amazon to curate a list of the best vintage pencils available, perfect for both writing aficionados and collectors alike. This article will highlight the top 10 products and provide an in-depth buying guide to assist you in making the right choice for your needs.

# Preview Product Rating Price
1 Retro/Shabby Chic/Vintage Typewriter Pencil Holder for Desk/Desk Organizer for Writer's Desk- Nostalgic Gift for Writers/Gift for Vintage Lovers/Gift for Typewriter Lovers Retro/Shabby Chic/Vintage Typewriter Pencil Holder for Desk/Desk Organizer for Writer's Desk-... No ratings yet $19.99
2 Cavallini Papers Pencil Set with 10 Pencils and 1 Sharpener, Vintage New York Cavallini Papers Pencil Set with 10 Pencils and 1 Sharpener, Vintage New York No ratings yet $11.45
3 Full Grain Genuine Handmade Leather Pencil Case Pouch, Multi-Purpose Storage Wrap for Scissors, Earphones, Pen & Pencil and Also Makeup Brushes (Brown) Full Grain Genuine Handmade Leather Pencil Case Pouch, Multi-Purpose Storage Wrap for Scissors,... No ratings yet $19.99
4 Mr. Pen- Mechanical Pencil Set with Leads and Eraser Refills, 5 Sizes - 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9 and 2 Millimeters, for Drafting, Drawing and Sketching Mr. Pen- Mechanical Pencil Set with Leads and Eraser Refills, 5 Sizes - 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9 and 2... No ratings yet $8.85
5 BERLINER BAGS Vintage Leather Pencil Case, Pen Pouch for Work and University or for Tobacco, for Men and Women - Brown BERLINER BAGS Vintage Leather Pencil Case, Pen Pouch for Work and University or for Tobacco, for Men... No ratings yet $15.99
6 DreamsEden Vintage Pen Pencil Holder Cup Retro Pattern Desk Organizer for Home Office Bedroom (Beige Paris Eiffel Tower Square) DreamsEden Vintage Pen Pencil Holder Cup Retro Pattern Desk Organizer for Home Office Bedroom (Beige... No ratings yet $9.99
7 Genuine Fred HAPPY CAMPER Vintage Camper Pencil Holder, White and Blue, Retro Desk Organizer- Great Gift for Coworkers and Travel Enthusiasts - Functional Desk & Cubicle Accessory Genuine Fred HAPPY CAMPER Vintage Camper Pencil Holder, White and Blue, Retro Desk Organizer- Great... No ratings yet $10.49
8 Cregugua Rustic Wooden Desk Organizer with 3 compartments Vintage Pen Pencil Holder (3.7x9.4x4.2 in) Cregugua Rustic Wooden Desk Organizer with 3 compartments Vintage Pen Pencil Holder (3.7x9.4x4.2 in) No ratings yet $9.99
9 Amoysanli Retro Typewriter Pen Holder Vintage Desk Accssories Unique Cool Gifts for Writer Typewriter Lovers and Secretary Cute Funny Pencil Cups for Office Home School (Bronze) Amoysanli Retro Typewriter Pen Holder Vintage Desk Accssories Unique Cool Gifts for Writer... No ratings yet $19.99
10 Vintage Typewriter Desk Organizer Pencil Holder for Desk Office Desk Accessories Desk Pencil Holder Retro Gift Vintage Desk Decor Desk Accessories Vintage Typewriter Desk Organizer Pencil Holder for Desk Office Desk Accessories Desk Pencil Holder... No ratings yet $19.94

Top 10 Vintage Pencils on Amazon

1. Vintage Wooden Pencils Set

Adding a touch of nostalgia to your writing experience, the Vintage Wooden Pencils Set includes a collection of beautifully crafted wooden pencils featuring classic designs and high-quality graphite cores. These pencils are perfect for sketching, writing, or simply displaying as part of your stationery collection. Whether you’re a student, an artist, or a vintage enthusiast, this set is sure to impress.

The wooden body is eco-friendly and ensures durability, while the comfortable grip makes it easy to use for extended periods. Plus, their classic design reflects the elegance of vintage craftsmanship, making them a great addition to any desk or pencil case.

Pros: Eco-friendly, durable, comfortable grip, classic design.

Cons: Limited color options.

Overall, the Vintage Wooden Pencils Set exemplifies the characteristics of the best vintage pencils best for writing enthusiasts.

OFF -$1.52Bestseller No. 1
DesignWorks Ink Old School Swear Words Engraved Pencil Set Includes 6 Wooden Graphite Pencils with 2 Carpenter Pencils & 4 No. 2 Pencils with Erasers in a Boxed Set, 6-Pieces
DesignWorks Ink Old School Swear Words Engraved Pencil Set Includes 6 Wooden Graphite Pencils with 2 Carpenter Pencils & 4 No. 2 Pencils with Erasers in a Boxed Set, 6-Pieces
  • KICK IT OLD SCHOOL: Premium boxed wood pencil set includes 2 carpenter and 4 hex pencils foil stamped with vintage swear words to spice up your cussin'; proudly made in the USA
  • PREMIUM QUALITY: Each pencil is made from real wood with #2 graphite lead for long-lasting, smooth, readable strokes; gold ferrules and soft, smudge-free erasers with for easy, clean corrections
  • ONE EACH OF: "Son Of A Biscuit!", Dang It All To Heck!", "Gosh Darn It!", What The Fudge?!", "Kiss My Grits!", "H-E-Double Hockey Sticks"
  • FOR LOVERS OF GREAT DESIGN: Search for DesignWorks Ink notebooks, pens, planners, pouches, and more that speak to every personality, whether bold and beautiful or understated and utilitarian
  • DESIGNWORKS INK: A Nashville-based design studio with innovative products for writers of notes, letters and stories as well as people who love great design, attention to detail, and exceptional quality

2. The Romantic Vintage Pencil Collection

This collection features meticulously designed pencils that exude romance and artistic flair. Each pencil is adorned with unique prints and finishes, and they come in an elegant box that adds a touch of sophistication. The variety in designs makes them ideal for gifting or as a delightful addition to your personal collection.

Not only do these pencils serve as functional writing instruments, but they are also a stunning decorative piece that elevates any workspace aesthetic. Their smooth writing experience is complemented by vibrant pigments that dazzle on paper.

Pros: Unique designs, elegant packaging, smooth writing.

Cons: Higher price due to design intricacies.

The Romantic Vintage Pencil Collection stands out as one of the best vintage pencils best suited for unique gifting opportunities and personal indulgence.

OFF -$5.07Bestseller No. 1
Cavallini Papers Pencil Set with 10 Pencils and 1 Sharpener, Vintage New York
Cavallini Papers Pencil Set with 10 Pencils and 1 Sharpener, Vintage New York
  • 10 pencils (5 per design) and a sharpener packaged in a tin
  • High quality pencils with HB lead
  • Tin Size: 8.75" x 2"
  • Country of Origin: China

3. Classic Graphite Pencils with Erasers

These classic graphite pencils come equipped with high-quality erasers, making them a practical choice for both artists and writers. The pencils are crafted from premium materials that promise longevity and consistent performance, whether used for sketching detailed illustrations or jotting down notes.

The design reflects traditional craftsmanship, which adds to its collectible value. With a range of hardness options, these pencils offer versatility and appeal to various writing styles.

Pros: High-quality erasers, durable materials, various hardness options.

Cons: Simple design might not appeal to everyone.

The Classic Graphite Pencils with Erasers are an integral part of the best vintage pencils best collection due to their balance of functionality and craftsmanship.

Bestseller No. 1
General Pencil 497BP Semi-Hex Graphite Drawing Pencils 4/Pkg-HB, 2B, 4B, & 6B, HB 2B 4B & 6B
General Pencil 497BP Semi-Hex Graphite Drawing Pencils 4/Pkg-HB, 2B, 4B, & 6B, HB 2B 4B & 6B
  • Diverse set of four high-quality graphite drawing pencils, encompassing HB, 2B, 4B, and 6B grades. Making your artwork come to life with clarity and expression.
  • Ergonomically designed semi-hex shape ensures comfort during extensive drawing sessions. Precision-crafted with the highest standards, trusted name in the art world for over a century.
  • Precision-crafted by General Pencil, a renowned name in art supplies for over a century. Comfortable grip, allowing you to focus on your art without discomfort.
  • Explore a broad spectrum of artistic expressions, from precise lines to rich shading. These pencils are designed to meet your diverse drawing needs.
  • Ideal for professional artists and enthusiastic hobbyists, offering exceptional drawing versatility. This set of four high-quality drawing pencils.

4. Retro Colored Pencil Set

For those who enjoy adding vibrant colors to their sketches or notes, the Retro Colored Pencil Set is an excellent choice. Featuring a range of bright colors, these vintage-inspired pencils are perfect for children, students, and creative professionals alike. The smooth application of color ensures that your artwork is bright and vivid, capturing the essence of vintage artistry.

The colored pencils are made from high-quality materials, ensuring they are safe for users of all ages. With a retro design, they serve both aesthetic and functional purposes, pleasing anyone who appreciates nostalgic art supplies.

Pros: Bright colors, smooth application, safe for all ages.

Cons: Color depth may vary between pencils.

The Retro Colored Pencil Set holds its own as one of the best vintage pencils best suited for anyone looking to infuse creativity into their writing or art.

OFF -$18.00Bestseller No. 1
Koh-I-Noor Polycolor Drawing Pencil Set, 24 Assorted Colored Pencils in a Retro Case, 1 Set Each (3824024020TK),Multicolor,14 x 3 x 1 cm
Koh-I-Noor Polycolor Drawing Pencil Set, 24 Assorted Colored Pencils in a Retro Case, 1 Set Each (3824024020TK),Multicolor,14 x 3 x 1 cm
  • Professional-grade pencils for drawing, illustrating and coloring are packaged in a traditional case from the first half of the 20th century
  • 3.8mm lead contains special oils to create water-resistant, dense and even strokes without using heavy pressure
  • Colors layer and blend beautifully with no waxy buildup
  • Broad edge excellent for shading; fine sharp point creates exquisite detail
  • Made from the finest Hardtmuth colors and encased with strong, durable California cedar

5. Antique Mechanical Pencils

For the vintage pencil collector, the Antique Mechanical Pencils make an exquisite addition to any collection. These mechanical pencils showcase intricate designs and exceptional craftsmanship. Each piece carries a story and reflects the elegance of the era it represents.

With mechanisms that offer a consistent lead flow, they are perfectly functional while serving as a stunning decorative piece. Made from high-quality materials, these mechanical pencils from different eras add a historical flair to your writing experience.

Pros: Intricate designs, functional and collectible, high-quality materials.

Cons: May require maintenance to preserve condition.

The Antique Mechanical Pencils are undoubtedly among the best vintage pencils best for seasoned collectors seeking timeless pieces.

Bestseller No. 1
Retro 51 Retro 1951, Tornado Douglass Pencil, Twist-Top with 1.1mm Lead (VRP-2120)
Retro 51 Retro 1951, Tornado Douglass Pencil, Twist-Top with 1.1mm Lead (VRP-2120)
  • Inspired by Frederick Douglass
  • Antique copper trim
  • Tactile computer engraved texture
  • Packaged in matching tube
  • Unit count: 1.0

6. Vintage Lead Pencil Collection

This Vintage Lead Pencil Collection includes a variety of lead pencils that echo an era of elegance and sophistication. Each pencil features unique designs and pastel colors that create a nostalgic atmosphere. Perfect for collectors, students, or anyone who enjoys writing with a classic pencil.

The pencils offer high-quality performance with sturdy leads, making them suitable for regular use while staying true to their vintage roots. Their charming aesthetics and practicality combine to make them truly appealing.

Pros: Unique designs, practical for everyday use, sturdy leads.

Cons: Limited availability due to collectible nature.

The Vintage Lead Pencil Collection solidifies its place as one of the best vintage pencils best for charm and functionality.

OFF -$3.00Bestseller No. 1
Mr. Pen- Mechanical Pencil Set with Leads and Eraser Refills, 5 Sizes - 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9 and 2 Millimeters, for Drafting, Drawing and Sketching
Mr. Pen- Mechanical Pencil Set with Leads and Eraser Refills, 5 Sizes - 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9 and 2 Millimeters, for Drafting, Drawing and Sketching
  • Mr. Pen vintage mechanical pencil set includes 5 quality pencils in 5 sizes: 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9, and 2.0 mm; set of 5 HB lead refills and 10 eraser refills. Each pencil has a comfortable grip for hours of writing comfort!
  • The mechanical pencil is made of high-quality material. The body provides ideal weight balance for fatigue-free writing and drawing. It brings you more effective and high-quality tasks.
  • Our mechanical pencil set is ideal for school or office use! The set comes packaged in a reusable box with an easy-to-close lid to keep the pencils organized and protected from damage when not in use!
  • Mr. Pen mechanical pencils set is perfect for everyday use. They are also great for art and technical drawing. The lead is very durable and will not break easily, making them a great choice for artists and professionals.
  • This mechanical pencil set by Mr. Pen is perfect for anyone, from architects and artists to students, teachers, and engineers. With 5 different pencil tip sizes, it's the ideal tool for any project.

7. Eco-Friendly Vintage Sketch Pencils

Taking care of our planet has never been more important, and the Eco-Friendly Vintage Sketch Pencils are a great choice for environmentally-conscious individuals. Made from sustainable wood and graphite, these pencils are perfect for artists and students who care about the planet.

The sketch pencils provide a smooth, consistent drawing experience, making them perfect for capturing your artistic visions. With their easy-to-sharpen design, these pencils are sure to accompany you in all your creative endeavors.

Pros: Eco-friendly materials, smooth performance, easy to sharpen.

Cons: Limited color options compared to colored pencils.

The Eco-Friendly Vintage Sketch Pencils embody the spirit of the best vintage pencils best while promoting sustainability.

Bestseller No. 1
Equo Recycled Newspaper Pencils (Pack of 5) - 100% Eco Friendly, Earth Friendly Pencil, Non Toxic Wood Free Pencil, 2B Pencil
Equo Recycled Newspaper Pencils (Pack of 5) - 100% Eco Friendly, Earth Friendly Pencil, Non Toxic Wood Free Pencil, 2B Pencil
  • Sustainable Materials: Made entirely from recycled newspapers, our pencils help reduce deforestation and minimize waste.
  • Eco-Friendly Design: With every stroke, celebrate the absence of plastic and wood, ensuring your writing journey leaves only a positive imprint on the planet.
  • High-Quality 2B Graphite Core: These pencils guarantee a smooth, enduring writing experience suitable for artists, writers, and students alike.
  • Versatile Use: Whether drafting sketches, jotting down notes, or shading art pieces, our pencils are as versatile as they are eco-conscious.
  • Raise Awareness: Each pencil stands as a statement of environmental responsibility and inspires change towards a more sustainable lifestyle.

8. Personalized Vintage Pencils

Add a personal touch to your writing tools with Personalized Vintage Pencils. These pencils can be customized with your name, favorite quote, or a special date, making them a fantastic gift for yourself or loved ones.

Crafted from high-quality wood, these pencils blend functionality with personalization, ensuring they look good while serving their practical purpose. Whether for writing, drawing, or simply as a keepsake, these pencils are a delightful blend of nostalgia and modern personal expression.

Pros: Customizable, high-quality wood, great for gifts.

Cons: Takes time for customization.

Personalized Vintage Pencils are a unique choice among the best vintage pencils best for gifting and personal flair.

Bestseller No. 1
OrcOw Personalized Pencils Bulk Custom Pencils with Name Customized Engraved #2 Triangular Pencil with Text Back to School Wedding Teacher's Day Gift, 10 Colors Set of 10
OrcOw Personalized Pencils Bulk Custom Pencils with Name Customized Engraved #2 Triangular Pencil with Text Back to School Wedding Teacher's Day Gift, 10 Colors Set of 10
  • HOW TO CUSTOMIZE: Click the "Customize Now" button and enter the name you want to customize. We will make it for you immediately after receiving your order.
  • HIGH QUALITY MATERIAL: Made of durable #2 wood with a triangular shape for a comfortable grip and smooth writing.
  • PRETTY COLORS: Engraved pencils are made of premium wood, eco-friendly and safe. We Provide 10 colors and they will be sure to leave a lasting impression on those who receive them.
  • SUITABLE FOR ALL AGES: Whether for a student, teacher or any friend, a personalized pencil makes a thoughtful gift appreciated by anyone. Great for back to school, birthdays or any day!
  • BETTER SERVICE: If you are worried about the poor customization effect, you can contact us to ask for a physical picture after purchase. Or contact us if you have any questions after receiving the product, we are happy to help you.

9. Nostalgic Pencil Sharpener Set

While not a pencil in itself, the Nostalgic Pencil Sharpener Set is a must-have for anyone who enjoys using vintage pencils. This set includes traditional sharpener designs that hark back to yesteryears, providing a charming way to keep your pencils sharp and ready for use.

These sharpeners are not only functional but also serve as a decorative addition to your desk. Made from high-quality materials, they are designed to last while adding an element of nostalgia to your workspace.

Pros: Charming designs, functional and decorative, high durability.

Cons: Limited to pencil sharpening utility.

The Nostalgic Pencil Sharpener Set complements your collection of the best vintage pencils best by ensuring they remain in excellent condition.

OFF -$1.30Bestseller No. 1
Bostitch Office Twist-n-Sharp Pencil Sharpener, For Kids & Colored Pencils, Assorted Colors (PS1-ADJ)
Bostitch Office Twist-n-Sharp Pencil Sharpener, For Kids & Colored Pencils, Assorted Colors (PS1-ADJ)
  • Premium Rachet Technology - Allows for comfortable and fast sharpening, unlike other pencil sharpeners
  • ATTACHED DISPENSER DRAWERS - An attached shavings dispenser doors allows you to clean the shaving easily but never lose the door piece
  • CUSTOMIZABLE SHARPENING – Center dial in center allow for sharp or blunt sharpening
  • TIP SAVER TECHNOLOGY - Prevents over-sharpening, making your pencils last longer. This technology is exclusive to Bostitch Pencil Sharpener
  • RECEIVE ONE OF 3 COLORS: Purple, Coral, or Blue (specific color cannot be guaranteed)

10. Vintage Artistic Pencil Set

Last but not least, the Vintage Artistic Pencil Set includes a variety of artistic pencils that cater to different mediums and styles. Whether for sketching, coloring, or shading, this set covers all bases and provides artists with a comprehensive selection of vintage pencils.

These pencils deliver exceptional performance, allowing artists to unleash their creativity onto paper seamlessly. The vintage-inspired aesthetics further make this set a delightful addition to any artist’s toolkit.

Pros: Versatile for various artistic needs, great performance, vintage aesthetics.

Cons: May not include all types of pencils desired by professional artists.

The Vintage Artistic Pencil Set rounds out the list of best vintage pencils best for artists and creative souls.

OFF -$3.00Bestseller No. 1
Mr. Pen- Mechanical Pencil Set with Leads and Eraser Refills, 5 Sizes - 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9 and 2 Millimeters, for Drafting, Drawing and Sketching
Mr. Pen- Mechanical Pencil Set with Leads and Eraser Refills, 5 Sizes - 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9 and 2 Millimeters, for Drafting, Drawing and Sketching
  • Mr. Pen vintage mechanical pencil set includes 5 quality pencils in 5 sizes: 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9, and 2.0 mm; set of 5 HB lead refills and 10 eraser refills. Each pencil has a comfortable grip for hours of writing comfort!
  • The mechanical pencil is made of high-quality material. The body provides ideal weight balance for fatigue-free writing and drawing. It brings you more effective and high-quality tasks.
  • Our mechanical pencil set is ideal for school or office use! The set comes packaged in a reusable box with an easy-to-close lid to keep the pencils organized and protected from damage when not in use!
  • Mr. Pen mechanical pencils set is perfect for everyday use. They are also great for art and technical drawing. The lead is very durable and will not break easily, making them a great choice for artists and professionals.
  • This mechanical pencil set by Mr. Pen is perfect for anyone, from architects and artists to students, teachers, and engineers. With 5 different pencil tip sizes, it's the ideal tool for any project.

Buying Guide for Vintage Pencils

Before making a purchase, it’s essential to consider several factors to ensure you are selecting the right set of vintage pencils for your needs:

1. Purpose

Determine what you will primarily use the pencils for — writing, drawing, or collecting. This will influence the type of pencils you should look for.

2. Material Quality

Check the material quality of the pencils. Look for options made from high-quality wood and durable leads for best performance.

3. Design

Consider the pencil design that aligns with your personal style. Vintage pencils come in various designs, so choose one that you find appealing.

4. Customization Options

For a more personalized experience, look for brands offering customization options that make it unique to you or a gift recipient.

5. Brand Reputation

Research brands to ensure they are reputable and known for producing quality vintage pencils. Customer reviews can give insight into performance and satisfaction.

6. Price

Vintage pencils can vary significantly in price. Determine your budget and find a balance between quality and affordability.

7. Availability

Some vintage pencil sets are collectible and may not be readily available. If you find a particular set you love, grab it before it’s gone, as stock can be limited.

In conclusion, whether you’re a writer, artist, or collector, investing in vintage pencils can bring a unique charm to your workspace. In 2024, the best vintage pencils best on Amazon offer a variety of designs and functionalities to cater to different preferences and needs. By following the buying guide, you can make an informed decision when selecting the perfect vintage pencils to add to your collection or daily use.

Last update on 2024-09-19 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API | votechriscarrillo.com is a participant in the Amazon Associate program and will earn from qualifying purchases.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *